I know that everybody and their brother has blogs with technical analysis. I do this primarily so that I actually pay attention to what the charts are telling me. I hope you, dear reader, find some value here. I think a couple of them are reasonably unusual and informative.
Two weeks ago the gold chart was looking pretty bearish. Here were the bearish factors I saw:
- Double-Top - reasonably well formed with the tops in Mar 08 and Feb 09. This bearish factor is still in place.
- 50 day moving average breakdown.
- 61.8% fibonacci breakdown (where the fibonacci high of Mar 08 and the low of Nov 08).
- Trendline breakdown.
- Psychologically important $900 round number breakdown.
- RSI turns down from 50 moving towards, but not beyond the 30 oversold level.
- Break down of support that looked like a ill-formed head and shoulders pattern.
The fundamentals improved a little over their already very strong situation (monetary growth, negative real interest rates, etc.) with:
- The return of Indian buying with the price of gold under $900. This puts a floor under the price of gold.
- The unveiling of ongoing Chinese buying and the movement of that bought gold into their monetary reserves (see previous post).
The technical situation has also improved with:
- A double-bounce off the 50% fibonnacci and 200 day moving average - the results of a bounce off the 200 day moving average has been very bullish for gold over the last few years (check for yourself). The double bounce also indicates a double-bottom. If the double-bottoms were further apart they would be more significant. I think this double-bounce is based on the fundamental fact that Indian buying kicks with gold under $900.
- A jump back above the psychologically important $900 value.
- A jump back above the 68% fibonacci number targetting a retest of the all time high of $1034.
- Bullish MACD crossover.
I know that some pretty respected commentators (Jeffrey Christian in Puplava's Financial Sense podcast today, David Morgan and others) are short-term bearish on the price of gold, but I'm somewhat relieved and am planning on holding at this point.
Large-cap gold mining stocks (as seen in the $HUI) look better with 50 day and 200 day moving average crossovers and with the RSI moving above 50 and with the $HUI forming a higher low.
The $HUI:$GOLD ratio chart shows the relative strength of large-cap gold mining stocks compared to the price of gold. It looks to me that the performance of gold mining stocks relative to gold itself bottomed last November and is reverting to historical levels. Its nice to see that trend line hold and the 200 day moving average cross over. At this point, I see, based on the last few years that commodities and financial markets have been strongly trending and that the 200 day moving average has been pretty good at capturing those trends. I expect, given the huge moves made recently that the next set of moves will also be large and that this trending factor will continue. As such, I have been paying more attention to 200 day moving average crossovers.
Here we have a look at the Dow Jones Industrial Average ($INDU) comparing the 2000 Internet Bubble crash with the 2008 Housing Bubble Crash. The S&P 500 chart looks very similar. Would be interesting to look at this in real (inflation adjusted) dollars, but I don't know how to do that. Any way, here's some observations:
- The 08 crash (so far) is worse than the 00 crash (at least for $INDU).
- The 00 bottom was shown to be in when there was a downturn that made a lower low. It occurred around 4.5 months after the lowest bottom. We have yet to see any kind of a higher bottom from the 08 crash, much less anything that far from the Mar 09 low.
- My conclusion is that the bottom is probably not in.
- NOTE: The volume bars (coming in from the right) show that there are a tonne of people who will heave a sigh of relief at not being losers and sell their stocks if the DJIA makes it between 10,500 and 11,000 anytime soon. If we actually get there it would be a good place to go short.
Silver looks pretty good having broken back above the 200 day moving average and the 61.8% fibonnacci line. Its also at a critical point and, if it can get above the 50 day moving average (and thus above that trend line) it will look very strong to retest that $14.5 recent high.
The USD, short-term, looks like its in trouble and a down day Monday would probably confirm it. Here's what's bearish:
- Popped over the 50 day moving average and immediately broke back down through it.
- Tested that 61.8% fibonacci number and immediately crashed down through the 50% and 38.1% fibonacci number. This targets the recent low just below 83.
- Broke through that trend line and closed just below it.
It seems likely to me that if the USD closes lower on Monday that it
will go all the way below 83 which, in the longer term charts, would
signal and even lower fall.
Currency markets are supposed to be the most driven by technicals of any of the markets so we could see a significant down-turn in the $USD. This has classically been bullish for precious metals.
30 Year US Treasury interest rates are taking an ominous turn upward breaking out above recent highs and the 200 day moving average. If this continues (or worse yet accelerates) its bad for lots of things:
- The US Dollar, as who is going to buy long-term US treasury bonds when rising interest rates cut their value. Argentina's 2001 currency collapse was preceded by rising interest rates.
- The US government deficit as rising interest rates mean higher payments on existing debts.
- Any kind of housing or commercial real-estate as a rising 30 year treasury pushes mortgage rates higher.
- The overall economy as rising interest rates slow down economic activity.
Copper is at a strategic point having completed its first down week in quite a while. It bounced off the psychologically important $2.25 level (having been pretty overbought as seen by the RSI), bounced right off that 200 day moving average and is clinging to that psychologically important $2.00 level. Another couple of closes below $2.00 could be bad.
Fundamentally, I see short term copper being strong because the LME inventory levels continue to fall. On the other hand, just about every existing copper mine can stay open at $2.00 copper. So long term, I just don't see copper staying above $2.00 until the global economy picks back up. I just don't see how the price can stay at a price that maintains supply when demand has fallen so much. We'll see.
Well, that's just the indices and the commodities. I may post a set of charts on individual stocks tomorrow.
MontyHigh, www.worldofwallstreet.us
I have several important questions for you:
1. Do you believe that gold stocks will tank in May this year? by that i mean that you must sell all your gold stocks because the gold price in May, June, July and August will decline immense?
A: Well, I'm really honored to have you ask me these questions. Anyone listening to me should consider that I'm just a software engineer who has been trying hard to figure out this investing thing. In the year leading up to July 2007 I made 3 million$ in Jr base metal mining stocks (nearly a triple) which has subsequently evaporated from holding too long and then moving to Jr gold producers as a safe have (which turned out to not be safe). So, I tend to go with what I believe in "all out" which results in very high volatility. I'm willing to take these risks because I consider myself diversified by having a lucrative, fairly secure day-job and by having a substantial, paid-off house.
So, firstly, you don't want to invest like me. You really need to form your own convictions and take responsibility for your own investment decisions.
You ask if I think gold stocks will tank in May this year. My answer is: I really don't know, but the stocks I hold should be able to print money if gold holds above $800. I expect to dump if I reach the conclusion that gold looks like it will drop below $800. I think the basic fundamentals for gold are really strong, with quantitative easing eventually leading to significant inflation and with big chances of other investments going to zero in the mean time. Finally, I like the fact that Asian buying (India, Vietnam, China) seems like its beginning to kick in and support a gold price of $880. Still, there's definitely a chance of a breakdown and I'm not going down with the ship, so I'm watching really, really carefully.
2. I hear everywhere that when inflation kicks in gold stocks will be worthless because the capital cost of gold mining will be huge and therefore the profits of these gold miners will be minimal.
Hard to know what will happen when inflation kicks in, but at $800 gold my gold mining Jrs should be able to print money. I think inflation drives inflation hedges like gold faster than gold mining costs (chief of which is salaries, secondarily crude oil). Anyway, look at Inca Kola's piece on gold mining vs gold (click here). His clear conclusion is that mining stocks are leveraged to the price of gold, so a rising price of gold (even if triggered by inflation) should be really good for the stocks I'm holding.
3. They say that there is now deflation, accroding to Jay Taylor gold stocks do extremely well in a deflationary environment. When will this deflationary influence end in the gold stock market.
I've heard Jay Taylor on gold stocks and deflation and the only data point I've seen is the Homestake Mining stock chart. That's just a data point. Homestake had a huge find that was barely economic at the start of the depression and that benefitted from falling mining prices. I consider it to be just a data point. But... my Jr mining stocks should be able to print money at $800 gold, so I'm holding as long as that seems like a good bet.
But really, you ask "when will deflation... end". That's the five dollar question that nobody really knows the answer to. My plan is to hold stocks that are making a tonne of money at current gold prices and to bail should the price of gold soften "too much".
4. Is it smart to sell your gold stocks end of April and buy back these same gold stocks in May, June, July and August because prices of these stocks will be low and cheap again.
Hard to say, but the stocks I'm holding are very illiquid and I expect to take a 5 to 10% hit every time I trade in and out, so I try not to do that. I'm really watching the gold chart carefully and if I think support has broken, I'm bailing and I don't know what I'll do next.
Beneath i have some gold stocks of which i am thinking to take also a position, i hope you can advice which stocks you think are worth taking a position in.
1. Pediment Exploration, PEZ
2. Castle Gold, CSG - Got a bunch of this and I like it.
3. Alexis Minerals, AMC
4. Allied Nevada Gold, ANV
5. Starcore International Mines, SAM - Risky play. They have a crappy, marginal mine and have had trouble getting it profitable. They are not big enough that they will ever be taken over. I recall some cases where it seemed to me that management cared more about themselves than stockholders.
6. Romarco Minerals, R
7. Hawthorne Gold, HGC
8. Sangold, SGR - Great rocks. Who knows how many oz though? Everybody and their brother is following it and is in already. Plus, have you visited the stockhouse board? What a swamp pit! I have stayed away (when I could have made money) because I just don't see how I have an edge. With this one, I woulda, coulda, shoulda.
9. New Guinea Gold, NGG - Terribly undervalued if they can get their starter mine working, but they keeping failing to do so. I've trimmed my holdings down to where I don't really mind if they go to zero. Production results for Q1 are due this week. If they are at 3500 oz or higher for the quarter then my confidence rises some.
10. AuEx Ventures, XAU
11. Animas Resources, ANI
12. Vista Gold, VGZ
13. Wesdome Gold, WDO
14. Eastmain resources, ER
15. Clifton Star, CFO
16. Canplats, CPQ
17. Premier Gold, PG
18. Rubicon Minerals, RMX
19. Andean Resources, AND
20. Lydian International, LYD
21. PDX Resources, PLG
Don't know anything about the rest of these. Other gold stocks I'm long on include: Gold Resource Corp, Dynasty Metals and Mining, Semafo, Troy Resources, Oceana Gold Corporation, La Mancha Resources and CGA Mining. I also hold some Impact Silver just because I really admire their management.
I want to thank you in advance.
I'm honored to have you ask my opinion, but one thing I realized about 5 years ago: Nobody cares about your money the way you do. I made a decision to take responsibility for my own investing decisions.
I sincerely would like your opinions.
Best of luck Ruud
I'll use this post as an excuse to put up my gold Jr fundamentals chart. The first chart is the stocks that I consider reference stocks to compare the others with (black), the second chart is my "less risky" favorites (blue, which are all probably too risky for a typical investor), followed by my "risky" favorites (green), followed by others that I've done in-depth due-diligence upon, but do not currently have large holdings of (dark red). All estimates are for 2010 and the price to operating cash flow is based on $800 gold.
Best wishes,
MontyHigh, www.worldofwallstreet.us